LAW ALERT: Employee Has No Right To Post-Termination Commissions
Published: July 7, 2009
In Nein v. HostPro, Inc., a Court of Appeal held that the language of the employee’s employment agreement precluded him from recovering commissions following his termination of employment. Plaintiff worked as a sales representative for HostPro for a period of 2 years. He signed an employment agreement that expressly provided that Plaintiff would be eligible for commission pay “so long as [he] remains employed with the Company as a Sales Representative.”
Plaintiff was terminated in December 2001. In January 2002, HostPro and a potential customer who Plaintiff had approached and negotiated with prior to his termination, completed the transaction. Plaintiff sued claiming he was entitled to commissions on the transaction. HostPro moved for summary judgment arguing that based on the terms of the employment agreement, it had no duty to pay Plaintiff commissions. The trial court granted summary judgment and Plaintiff appealed. The Court of Appeal agreed. It said that the employment agreement was “susceptible to only one interpretation – that once plaintiff ceased to be employed by defendant, he would no longer be eligible for commission pay.”
CAUTIONARY NOTE: Despite the ruling in HostPro, employers should be careful when drafting commission plans and consult with their employment counsel since there are other cases which have interpreted similar language as punitive and resulting in a forfeiture of commissions when the sales was ultimately consummated based on the efforts of the employee prior to termination.
Lizbeth “Beth” West is a shareholder in the Labor and Employment Law Section and Disputes, Trials & Appeals Section at Weintraub Genshlea Chediak. Beth’s practice focuses on counseling employers in all areas of employment law, and defending employers in state and federal court, as well as before administrative agencies. She has extensive experience in defending wage and hour claims, and complex whistle-blowing and retaliation claims. She also provides training services on various employment issues, such as sexual harassment and violence in the workplace. If you have any questions about this Legal Alert or other employment law related questions, please feel free to contact Beth West at (916) 558-6082. For additional articles on employment law issues, please visit Weintraub’s law blog at www.thelelawblog.com.